Effectful

Integration with most of existing libraries and frameworks can be done quite easily. The main difference in how that looks like depends on the way a library operates in a monadic context.

There are three main groups a library might fall into. It either operates:

1) In a monad of your application transformed by a library specific monad transformer.

2) In its own, concrete monad, which is usually IO or a couple of monad transformers on top of IO.

3) In a polymorphic monad, which is constrained by a type class that implements core operations of a library.

Each case needs a slightly different approach to integrate with the Eff monad.

These are libraries that provide a custom transformer for the main monad of your application and their operations make use of it for their operations. Examples include InputT from the haskeline package or ConduitT from the conduit package.

These libraries can trivially be used with the Eff monad since it provides typical instances that these libraries require the underlying monad to have, such as MonadMask or MonadUnliftIO.

In case the Eff monad doesn't provide a specific instance out of the box, it can be supplied via an effect. As an example see how the instance of MonadResource for Eff is implemented in the resourcet-effectful package.

If a library operates in IO, there are a couple of ways to integrate it.

The easiest way is to use its functions selectively in the Eff monad with the help of liftIO or withEffToIO. However, this is not particularly robust, since it vastly broadens the scope in which the IOE effect is needed (not to mention that explicit lifting is annoying).

A somewhat better approach is to create a dummy static effect with lightweight wrappers of the library functions. As an example have a look at the Effectful.Concurrent.Async module from the effectful package that wraps the API of the async package. Unfortunately, this requires the amount of work proportional to the size of the library and might not be the best option, especially if you only need to make use of a tiny portion of the API.

Even better (though sometimes hard to do in practice) way is to consider, what do you need the library for and then create a custom effect with high level operations that the library in question will help us implement. The advantage of this approach is that we're hiding implementation details from the so-called "business logic" of our application and make it possible to easily swap them in different environments or during future refactoring.

Some libraries operate in a transformer stack over IO or have its own concrete monad that's a newtype over IO, e.g. Handler from the servant-server package.

In such case it's best to mirror the monad in question by the Eff monad with appropriate effects (as most popular monad transformers have subtle issues), use it as soon as possible, then at the end feed the final state to the monad of the library so it proceeds as if nothing unusual happened.

As an example, consider the following monad:

>>> import qualified Control.Monad.State as T>>> import qualified Control.Monad.Except as T

>>> data HandlerState>>> data HandlerError

>>> :{  newtype Handler a = Handler (T.ExceptT HandlerError (T.StateT HandlerState IO) a)    deriving ( Applicative, Functor, Monad, MonadIO             , T.MonadState HandlerState, T.MonadError HandlerError             ):}

This is how you can execute Eff actions in the Handler monad:

>>> import Effectful.Error.Static>>> import Effectful.State.Static.Local

>>> :{  effToHandler :: Eff [Error HandlerError, State HandlerState, IOE] a -> Handler a  effToHandler m = do    -- Retrieve the current state of the Handler.    s <- T.get    -- Run the Eff monad with effects mirroring the capabilities of @Handler@.    (er, s') <- liftIO . runEff . runState s . runErrorNoCallStack @HandlerError $ m    -- Update the state of the Handler and throw an error if appropriate.    T.put s'    either T.throwError pure er:}

Libraries working in a polymorphic monad use mtl style effects. Details about their integration with the Eff monad require familiarity with dynamically dispatched effects and thus are available in the Effectful.Dispatch.Dynamic#integration module.